Personally for me, RDR2. I find the gameplay not as smooth as I was hoping.
Mind you I played this game when it released and loved it, took a week off work and played the whole week!
I moved to a PC and left behind my console. So I didn’t touch it for years.
I tried going back last week and was dissatisfied. The combat felt so clunky. And the overall world looks dull to me.
But that’s just my opinion, I can obviously see why there is love for the game!
It’s probably not a bad game, but they combined Dark Souls and Skyrim together and I played them both to literal death. So it was really hard to even find motivation to play it, without a clear progressions and dungeons this just didn’t feel right to me. I am glad the game is successful so hopefully we’ll get a “weird side story” similar to Majora’s Mask sometime soon.