@ToothPickLegs just posted the opposite of this, but who are your all time under the radar players that never got enough love? I’ll go first with Tyson AluAlu between 2017-2020 before the foot injury. Going from basically a bust in Jacksonville to holding down the middle and anchoring the run defense for a number of years for the Steelers feels like it went unnoticed. In 2021 when he was injured the run D fell off a cliff too.
Also on the same note, Mewelde Moore in 2008. He had some good games for us on the way to the title that year spelling Parker and being the 3rd down back. Good player.