Caleb Williams legitimately is stumbling bad down the stretch. Bad losses to rivals Notre Dame and now UCLA in what is likely his final college game.
What’s everyone think? Is he “Generational”, a Top-3 QB prospect, or the next Johnny Manziel?
If it means anything, 2 main guys on the Athletic that live and breath the college game (Dane and Mike) have planted their flags.
-
Dan Brugler (Hes famous for his monster ‘The Beast’ draft guide) recently changed Maye to the top guy.
-
Nate Tice has had Maye as his top QB guy forever, way before Caleb’s off games recently.
Id say, hes not generational, but noone will ever be Manziel again. Johnny was literally the biggest and largest red flag in recent memory. Its no way fair to put Caleb there (but i know what you mean by bringing Manziel up).
Caleb is looking like “just” a top 3 guy and I put quotes around just bc that shouldnt be frowned upon. Theres a bunch of people on this sub saying to basically ignore what he has been struggling with and to just listen to the generational stuff. Why would you do that? You need to look at film at the end of the day and not remember his hype. His film recently has been less than generational. But, that doesnt mean he cant be good at the next level.
Its really weird around here. Its like people on the sub are already protecting Caleb, thinking hes going to be the next bears QB.
-
OP genuinely thought he was cooking with this post
I don’t watch college football so I don’t know the answer to this but why isn’t Bo Nix considered a top prospect?
Just read an article saying they expect him to be drafted in the second round. Is he just putting up empty stats against bad defenses or something?
His completion percentage and TD/int are really good but obviously without watching any of the games I don’t have any context for his numbers.
Qb wins only matter when its not Fields
if performance in college mattered for performance in nfl, drafting wouldn’t be such a crap shoot that it is.
I have my doubts of Caleb. The same people hyping up mitchell are hyping up him. We’re getting “generational” prospects every 2-3 years. His rumored refusing to play for certain teams are red flags. But the people making this decision hopefully aren’t as dumb as me. And aren’t as dumb as the so called experts that missed so hard on Mitchell.
I want Caleb Williams to look as bad as possible. If we need a QB and only have 1.02, then that should help us land him.
There has to be something that can be said for caleb’s sake that all of the arguments I see against him are dumb as fuck.