Story and ambiance/world building actually. Visual style is much more important than visual fidelity also.

Both, but maybe gameplay a bit more

I like graphics, It’s what keeps me buying new consoles…But gameplay is FOREVER.

Definitely gameplay

Gameplay for sure. The graphics need to be good enough that the game feels good to play, but they don’t need anything crazy as long as the gameplay is phenomenal. In general, if the gameplay is bad, I’ll quit after a few hours despite great graphics

Gameplay

I don’t even notice graphics passed the first hour or two.

Can go from an N64 game to a Series X game to a Switch game back to a PS2 or SNES game and enjoy myself in each one.

Narrative > Everything
Gameplay > Graphics

Gameplay, but I also don’t wanna be bogged down by a broken pos.

Gameplay, obviously. I don’t care whatsoever about graphics as long as I know what everything is, appearance wise.

Think about GTA San Andreas

The graphics by todays standart is bad but i think it’s a lot better than GTA 5

No contest, gameplay here.