I’m not talking about superspeedways, that’s exactly the scenario where downshifting wouldn’t make sense because a car will not achieve its top speed in a lower gear. I don’t know much about nascar as a European, but the races I (rarely) watch have much more turns and they don’t reach top speeds except for tracks like Monza with its very long straights. I don’t think they will always even be in their highest gear between two turns.
When I was driving my own manual car it definitely helped to shift down to overtake a car, even at higher speeds. It’s a short but noticeable boost.
I also ride a road (racing) bike and both the drafting and downshift are very noticeable. When you draft you can shift up and cycle at lower cadence with much less effort. Then if you want to overtake you can accelerate much faster in the lower gear than you would at the higher gear. Of course you can also stay in the higher gear and stand up on the pedals, but that is like turning on another engine (engaging different muscles), which is an option a car simply doesn’t have.
So in short, I still don’t see how a racing car engine is so different that these simple laws of physics wouldn’t apply.
Did you miss the part where, by your own logic, as well as by actual racing practice, the driver wouldn’t shift into the higher gear if there’s still acceleration left in the lower gear? If you find that you can downshift to go faster, that just means that your upshifting pattern is dumb and wrong.
At this point you’re either confused beyond repair in this topic and can’t even see it, or are just smoothsharking and pretending to be thick — neither of which make a good case for continuing trying to make you see the light.
At least, thankfully, it’s not my car in which you’re cruising in the fifth gear when you should be in the third. You can do that to your own car as much as you want.
I’m not talking about superspeedways, that’s exactly the scenario where downshifting wouldn’t make sense because a car will not achieve its top speed in a lower gear. I don’t know much about nascar as a European, but the races I (rarely) watch have much more turns and they don’t reach top speeds except for tracks like Monza with its very long straights. I don’t think they will always even be in their highest gear between two turns.
When I was driving my own manual car it definitely helped to shift down to overtake a car, even at higher speeds. It’s a short but noticeable boost.
I also ride a road (racing) bike and both the drafting and downshift are very noticeable. When you draft you can shift up and cycle at lower cadence with much less effort. Then if you want to overtake you can accelerate much faster in the lower gear than you would at the higher gear. Of course you can also stay in the higher gear and stand up on the pedals, but that is like turning on another engine (engaging different muscles), which is an option a car simply doesn’t have.
So in short, I still don’t see how a racing car engine is so different that these simple laws of physics wouldn’t apply.
Did you miss the part where, by your own logic, as well as by actual racing practice, the driver wouldn’t shift into the higher gear if there’s still acceleration left in the lower gear? If you find that you can downshift to go faster, that just means that your upshifting pattern is dumb and wrong.
At this point you’re either confused beyond repair in this topic and can’t even see it, or are just smoothsharking and pretending to be thick — neither of which make a good case for continuing trying to make you see the light.
No need to become pedantic again… let’s have a grown up discussion on Lemmy, not a slap fight on Reddit.
Maybe you misread that.
Not if they know anything about Newton’s second law.
Both doubtful.
I simply disagree with you and you haven’t made a decent case.
Seeing as this is going the wrong way again, I’m once again disengaging and blocking. Goodbye.
At least, thankfully, it’s not my car in which you’re cruising in the fifth gear when you should be in the third. You can do that to your own car as much as you want.