You’ll get no argument from me on the cruelty of the meat industry. It is certainly a moral issue, and the profit driven food system is objectively wrong.
That said, the separate issue of the desire to eat meat is something that very much exists in nature. Many animals in the world eat meat. Slavery, like factory farms, is a capitalistic creation that is not natural, but desiring to eating meat very much is.
Humans have omnivorous teeth. Evolution made us capable of both diets. That is nobody’s fault, that’s just the way the cookie crumbled.
So, in a vacuum, it is quite possible for someone to hunt or raise their own meat and consume it without participating in the factory farm system at all, which would be nothing more than an animal engaging in the diet that evolution designed them to be able to ingest.
“That said, the separate issue of the desire to eat meat is something that very much exists in nature.”
As Kefla already pointed out, what we find in nature is not an excuse for us to do the same. That is more than enough reason to defeat your excuse for treating sentient life as an object to sate our desire, so I won’t get into that (yet).
But even setting that aside for now, let’s take what you said about “the separate issue of the desire to eat meat” at face value. If it exists at all, whatever biologically innate “desire” to specifically eat meat humans might have is utterly swamped by cultural influences. We are, above all, a social species, and people will heavily tend towards food preferences that reflect those of the society they exist within. In a culture that eats a primarily plant-based diet, its members will strongly prefer primarily plant-based foods. We are highly adaptable. Even within a single individual, as most vegetarians and vegans are testament to, your food preferences are malleable to fit what is available. I for example have no desire whatsoever to eat meat. I am not denying some biological drive to eat animal flesh, despite having once thought it tasted good. What carnist apologists act like is some deep-seated physiological drive or need to eat meat is simply a myth.
Humans have omnivorous teeth.
The teeth of homo sapiens are far far more similar to herbivores than to carnivore or omnivores. Omnivores like raccoons, many canids, bears (who aside from polar bears have a diet of around 70% plants), etc all have teeth more like carnivores than like herbivores or humans. Their canines/cuspids are longer than the surrounding teeth, whereas ours, along with strict herbivores are even with the surrounding teeth. Much more telling are our molars. Humans, like herbivores have large and flatened-surface molars with complexly dented crowns for grinding plant matter. The animals consideredto be true natural omnivores do not have those kinds of molars.
And this is true of all sorts of aspects of our anatomy, from gut length to kidney function (concentration of urine - ours, like herbivores is highly dilute in comparison to both carnivores and omnivores), to what we have at the ends of our limbs (flat nails instead of sharp claws as on omnivores). But it is amusing you chose teeth because those are one of the more prominently herbivorous traits we have.
Clearly humans are capable of eating meat and what an evolutionary advantage it must have been to be able to eat it when the opportunity arose! And obviously our physiology reflects this ability to eat meat. But that does not change the fact that physiologically we resemble herbivores much more than we do omnivores who need to retain many traits of carnivores (tgat we humans do not share) in order to take advantage of regular, continuous meat and plant sources of food. We are herbivores with the opportunistic ability to eat meat.
So, in a vacuum, it is quite possible for someone to hunt or raise their own meat and consume it without participating in the factory farm system at all
While it is undeniably good and a massive step in the right direction to reject the consumption of factory farmed sentient beings, it’s still no excuse to hunt or raise animals for food in the modern age especially in a developed country. We do not need it (and indeed are generally healthier without it) and to knowingly, willingly cause unnecessary suffering and death is wrong at the most fundamental level of our morality. All of us here (I would hope) recognize this with respect to other human beings: we would not tolerate behavior like raising people for the sake of killing them and eating them (or using their bodies against their will for our pleasure in whatever way, regardless of literally consuming their flesh or not). Someone who supports doing that to nonhumans creatures, beings who have thoughts and emotions, who experience fear and have desires, must make up reasons for why it is at the very least morally neutral to disregard that suffering and use nonhuman bodies and lives to fulfill their desires. And there simply is no good, valid excuse tgat cannot also apply to doing the same to other humans. The most common attempt to reason a way out of this fact, the very excuse you’ve brought up here, can be summed up as the naturalistic fallacy. But it is an excuse that works no better than as an excuse to do to other people whatever we want, since e.g. murderous rage is also clearly something prevalent in our evolutionary history, a natural aspect of our humanity, though we should not excuse those who indulge in it, and it is well within our capacity to choose not to indulge in it.
You know the reason your brain is so big and juicy is because our intelligent ancestors used fire to cook and eat the delicious fatty marrow contained in the bones of our prey? This nutrient boost allowed us to grow much larger and more complex brains.
Animals do all kinds of horrible things that we do not excuse in humans existing in a society. Murder of babies, cannibalism, sexual violence, exiling young adults from their families in order to force them to go form their own families, all of these are things animals do all the time.
You are different because you’re a moral agent. You have the ability to understand morality and thus you have the obligation to behave according to some moral standard. Slaughtering innocents unnecessarily for the sake of personal pleasure violates any reasonable moral standard.
Oh ok you’re right, morality is subjective which means it doesn’t matter. Everybody go back to doing slavery, this liberal figured out the hack to avoiding criticism on moral grounds.
You’re right, I was mistaken when I responded to what you said as if you had a point. Since you had no point to begin with, any such assumption would be a strawman.
I think this is a fair compromise that reduces meat consumption and makes people more aware of where they’re getting their food from. If you want to eat meat, you have to hunt/ethically kill (relatively speaking) an animal to get it
Do not lie to me that you actually think it would be ethical for me to sneak up on you in the retirement home and shoot you in the back of the head. Beyond that, don’t lie to yourself. The reason you can’t speak honestly here is because your position is illogical and you know it.
Also, you think hunters are only hunting elderly animals?
I would rather be killed than lie there growing older while my body falls apart, waiting to die a prolonged death. And when did I say that hunters only hunt elderly animals?
Your previous comment was, and I quote: “do it quickly and painlessly, after i’ve already lived a long life?”.
Which I take to mean that in your mind the “ethical” way to hunt an animal that doesn’t want to die is to kill them quickly and painlessly, after they’ve lived a long life. That is, when the animal being hunted is old. So what hunters actually do (usually kill animals in the prime of their life), would be, in your mind, fairly unethical.
That’s why Kefla said what she did, she was pointing out that hunters don’t only kill elderly animals, so they don’t treat their victims in the way you have stated you would find ethical.
I’m continually annoyed with the way people on the internet are incapable of following any sort of conversation. It annoys the shit out of me that basic conversational norms are apparently impossible for many people on the internet to understand, much less abide by. If you feel like the people you’re talking to are misunderstanding what you’re saying, try saying it again! Don’t just say (or, in your case imply) that people are putting words in your mouth when the obvious reading of what you’ve said is argued against!
Yes, that is a correct interpretation of my previous comment. I know that hunters don’t only kill elderly animals, but I thought it was obvious we were talking about how animals SHOULD be killed, not how they are CURRENTLY killed. If that wasn’t as clear as I thought, then that’s my bad. From my perspective, saying I think that hunters only hunt elderly animals just seemed like an insult so I didn’t write a detailed response.
You’ll get no argument from me on the cruelty of the meat industry. It is certainly a moral issue, and the profit driven food system is objectively wrong.
That said, the separate issue of the desire to eat meat is something that very much exists in nature. Many animals in the world eat meat. Slavery, like factory farms, is a capitalistic creation that is not natural, but desiring to eating meat very much is.
Humans have omnivorous teeth. Evolution made us capable of both diets. That is nobody’s fault, that’s just the way the cookie crumbled.
So, in a vacuum, it is quite possible for someone to hunt or raise their own meat and consume it without participating in the factory farm system at all, which would be nothing more than an animal engaging in the diet that evolution designed them to be able to ingest.
As Kefla already pointed out, what we find in nature is not an excuse for us to do the same. That is more than enough reason to defeat your excuse for treating sentient life as an object to sate our desire, so I won’t get into that (yet).
But even setting that aside for now, let’s take what you said about “the separate issue of the desire to eat meat” at face value. If it exists at all, whatever biologically innate “desire” to specifically eat meat humans might have is utterly swamped by cultural influences. We are, above all, a social species, and people will heavily tend towards food preferences that reflect those of the society they exist within. In a culture that eats a primarily plant-based diet, its members will strongly prefer primarily plant-based foods. We are highly adaptable. Even within a single individual, as most vegetarians and vegans are testament to, your food preferences are malleable to fit what is available. I for example have no desire whatsoever to eat meat. I am not denying some biological drive to eat animal flesh, despite having once thought it tasted good. What carnist apologists act like is some deep-seated physiological drive or need to eat meat is simply a myth.
The teeth of homo sapiens are far far more similar to herbivores than to carnivore or omnivores. Omnivores like raccoons, many canids, bears (who aside from polar bears have a diet of around 70% plants), etc all have teeth more like carnivores than like herbivores or humans. Their canines/cuspids are longer than the surrounding teeth, whereas ours, along with strict herbivores are even with the surrounding teeth. Much more telling are our molars. Humans, like herbivores have large and flatened-surface molars with complexly dented crowns for grinding plant matter. The animals consideredto be true natural omnivores do not have those kinds of molars.
And this is true of all sorts of aspects of our anatomy, from gut length to kidney function (concentration of urine - ours, like herbivores is highly dilute in comparison to both carnivores and omnivores), to what we have at the ends of our limbs (flat nails instead of sharp claws as on omnivores). But it is amusing you chose teeth because those are one of the more prominently herbivorous traits we have.
Clearly humans are capable of eating meat and what an evolutionary advantage it must have been to be able to eat it when the opportunity arose! And obviously our physiology reflects this ability to eat meat. But that does not change the fact that physiologically we resemble herbivores much more than we do omnivores who need to retain many traits of carnivores (tgat we humans do not share) in order to take advantage of regular, continuous meat and plant sources of food. We are herbivores with the opportunistic ability to eat meat.
While it is undeniably good and a massive step in the right direction to reject the consumption of factory farmed sentient beings, it’s still no excuse to hunt or raise animals for food in the modern age especially in a developed country. We do not need it (and indeed are generally healthier without it) and to knowingly, willingly cause unnecessary suffering and death is wrong at the most fundamental level of our morality. All of us here (I would hope) recognize this with respect to other human beings: we would not tolerate behavior like raising people for the sake of killing them and eating them (or using their bodies against their will for our pleasure in whatever way, regardless of literally consuming their flesh or not). Someone who supports doing that to nonhumans creatures, beings who have thoughts and emotions, who experience fear and have desires, must make up reasons for why it is at the very least morally neutral to disregard that suffering and use nonhuman bodies and lives to fulfill their desires. And there simply is no good, valid excuse tgat cannot also apply to doing the same to other humans. The most common attempt to reason a way out of this fact, the very excuse you’ve brought up here, can be summed up as the naturalistic fallacy. But it is an excuse that works no better than as an excuse to do to other people whatever we want, since e.g. murderous rage is also clearly something prevalent in our evolutionary history, a natural aspect of our humanity, though we should not excuse those who indulge in it, and it is well within our capacity to choose not to indulge in it.
You know the reason your brain is so big and juicy is because our intelligent ancestors used fire to cook and eat the delicious fatty marrow contained in the bones of our prey? This nutrient boost allowed us to grow much larger and more complex brains.
Repost without the dickheadedness, my apologies.
Removed by mod
Animals do all kinds of horrible things that we do not excuse in humans existing in a society. Murder of babies, cannibalism, sexual violence, exiling young adults from their families in order to force them to go form their own families, all of these are things animals do all the time.
You are different because you’re a moral agent. You have the ability to understand morality and thus you have the obligation to behave according to some moral standard. Slaughtering innocents unnecessarily for the sake of personal pleasure violates any reasonable moral standard.
Tbh though, it can also be argued that plants are on some level sentient. The difference is just where you draw the line.
No it fucking can’t.
If you want to minimize your harm to plants, you need to go vegan. Raising animals also requires farming plants.
Humans aren’t the only species to exhibit behavior representing morality, and also morality is subjective anyways
Oh ok you’re right, morality is subjective which means it doesn’t matter. Everybody go back to doing slavery, this liberal figured out the hack to avoiding criticism on moral grounds.
W Strawman
You’re right, I was mistaken when I responded to what you said as if you had a point. Since you had no point to begin with, any such assumption would be a strawman.
I think this is a fair compromise that reduces meat consumption and makes people more aware of where they’re getting their food from. If you want to eat meat, you have to hunt/ethically kill (relatively speaking) an animal to get it
Let’s say I’ve made the personal choice to kill and eat you. How exactly do I hunt you ethically?
do it quickly and painlessly, after i’ve already lived a long life?
Do not lie to me that you actually think it would be ethical for me to sneak up on you in the retirement home and shoot you in the back of the head. Beyond that, don’t lie to yourself. The reason you can’t speak honestly here is because your position is illogical and you know it.
Also, you think hunters are only hunting elderly animals?
I would rather be killed than lie there growing older while my body falls apart, waiting to die a prolonged death. And when did I say that hunters only hunt elderly animals?
Your previous comment was, and I quote: “do it quickly and painlessly, after i’ve already lived a long life?”.
Which I take to mean that in your mind the “ethical” way to hunt an animal that doesn’t want to die is to kill them quickly and painlessly, after they’ve lived a long life. That is, when the animal being hunted is old. So what hunters actually do (usually kill animals in the prime of their life), would be, in your mind, fairly unethical.
That’s why Kefla said what she did, she was pointing out that hunters don’t only kill elderly animals, so they don’t treat their victims in the way you have stated you would find ethical.
I’m continually annoyed with the way people on the internet are incapable of following any sort of conversation. It annoys the shit out of me that basic conversational norms are apparently impossible for many people on the internet to understand, much less abide by. If you feel like the people you’re talking to are misunderstanding what you’re saying, try saying it again! Don’t just say (or, in your case imply) that people are putting words in your mouth when the obvious reading of what you’ve said is argued against!
Yes, that is a correct interpretation of my previous comment. I know that hunters don’t only kill elderly animals, but I thought it was obvious we were talking about how animals SHOULD be killed, not how they are CURRENTLY killed. If that wasn’t as clear as I thought, then that’s my bad. From my perspective, saying I think that hunters only hunt elderly animals just seemed like an insult so I didn’t write a detailed response.
So why do you wanna kill grandparents?