Finally time to replace my old TV after 10+ years, and my god the market is full of ad-boxes.
I’ve heard Sceptre is the brand to look for, but I googled half a dozen of the 50-inch model numbers from their website and can’t find one that anyone’s actually selling right now.
Impecca is solid. I got their 43 inch non smart TV for my aging parent a few months ago. I had a hard time finding any of their larger TVs when I checked more recently though.
considering the screen quality, i would just get a “smart” one from lg/samsung/etc, rooting it and using offline. not sure of the specific model but i remember hearing someone saying some lg tvs are easily rooted and debloated.
I have a few sizes of Samsung digital commercial signage displays. yes, they do have WiFi capability and some apps. But their designed to work fine without a net connection and the price was a bit better than the truly “dumb” TVs I was finding.
I was looking for a good 65" OLED 4k hospitality TV, could only find them for like, $3k. Is that about what you paid?
I got a 55" BEFX for $470 and a 43" BEFX for $350. Looks like the 65" version is under $1k.
edit: not OLED, though.
My mother bought a new small Roku TV for her kitchen, when I set it up there was no way to bypass connecting it to the Internet and logging in with a Roku account. I resorted to using my phone’s hotspot for the initial setup so that it could auto connect to her home wifi.
Avoid Roku like the plague. Shit company with shit products.
I bought my Sceptre about 8 years ago. 50" 4k dumb TV. Perfect.
Looks like in recent years they’ve gone to gaming monitors only. Hisense or Insignia might have a dumb version.
We use a projector on our wall. Has served us well
I did this for a while. On shopgoodwill.com, I found several old projectors in good condition for cheap.
Your options are pretty much either a smart tv you never give internet access to or a commercial display. Commercial displays are exactly what you’re looking for but much more expensive.
This might be a dumb question, but can’t you just get any TV you like, and simply not give it internet access?
A lot of those TVs are found to seek out Internet access through open access points, which a lot of Internet provider’s routers now provide. You might not have one, but your neighbor might. They also listen for shitloads of key words and note them, along with what devices where present and what time they were said. The shit is absolutely insidious.
Oh really? Jeez, I didn’t know that. Very creepy 😦
My plan is to open it up and physically remove nic card.
They also listen for shitloads of key words and note them, along with what devices where present and what time they were said. The shit is absolutely insidious.
Pretty sure I read the other day about how a smart TV quit working because it had been disconnected from the internet long enough that the microphone transcripts it had been trying to phone home filled up its memory.
For what it’s worth, my LG OLEDs have been disconnected from the internet for a while (a C9 since 2020 and a C2 since 2023) and I haven’t had any issues like this. There’s no public wifi networks around me either.
I have LG, TCL and Samsung TVs that have never been connected to the internet and they have worked fine for years.
Also I’m unaware of any mainstream TVs that autonomously connect to wireless networks.
Also I’m unaware of any mainstream TVs that autonomously connect to wireless networks.
How would you know they are, though?
It may come to that, but I’ve heard too many people bitching about their TV either constantly begging for wifi, or seeking out an open network on its own, to be comfortable with making that my first move.
Our Sony TVs do no such thing. They also have a “old person mode” interface that is delightfully simple.
If the idea still bothers you though, plug in an Ethernet cable that goes nowhere, or connect to WiFi and firewall it off. Then it can’t search for new networks.
You connect it to your home network, you just shut off its outside connection at the router. I do this for my TV and all my displays, and have never had a problem.
wait so you connect it to your normal router then go into the router and tell it that those devices have zero internet access? or do you mean that you hook it to a new router that is just for the tv?
I do the first thing you said.
Either. A router just for devices(1) to be totally denied Internet access is likely the cheapest way to go, but beware devices that demand talking to their mothership like the most recent Roku ones and there will be more noise impacting your real network. Routers that can allow association but not Internet access to specific devices are more expensive or require more effort (e.g., installing ddwrt).
(1) Actually MAC addresses, which can be spoofed and some devices might periodically change to one randomly generated. The former to intentionally avoid blocks while the latter might be to enhance privacy that might also “happen” to avoid blocks.
Routers that can allow association but not Internet access to specific devices are more expensive or require more effort
Most routers should have a firewall. You’d just need to create an outbound firewall rule rather than an inbound one.
The better routers and wifi access points let you create separate isolated VLANs, and separate wifi networks that use VLANs. That’s a nicer approach, but you definitely need higher end hardware for that.
I’ve got four VLANs on my home network:
- My main network, with only trusted devices on it
- Devices that don’t need internet access
- IoT devices that need internet access
- Guests
The latter three all have client isolation enabled (devices on those networks can’t see or connect to any other devices on the network) and the “non internet access one”, as the name suggests, has no internet access at all. I use these for both wired and wireless devices (I’ve got four wifi SSIDs that correspond to the four VLANs)
I like the VLAN idea! I’m going to look into that.
Hm, if I look at Android, it might change network if it detects no network access. At least it switches from wifi to mobile.
If devices start using mobile capable chipsets that’s certainly a possible result. Even sticking with just WiFi we might see them looking for an open (guest?) network or a partnership with a widespread WiFi provider like CableWiFi. The latter might even be provided by your own cable box or your neighbor’s, or similar if fixed mobile starts doing the same.
I have to say that I frigging hate the naggy slow interfaces of the new “smart” TVs. When you have to do a reset dance just to get it to boot properly (in mins), just doesn’t seem like it’s worth putting up with even if it doesn’t report home. And of course it bitches when it doesn’t have internet too. Android TV does not belong in existence, nor anyone else’s idea of smart TVs
My recommendation would be to get an LG OLED and just never connect it to your wifi (or connect it to a separate SSID and VLAN that doesn’t have internet access), but that’d be on the pricier side.
I can’t imagine a worse recommendation for OP.
Why? They’re good TVs and they usually go on sale for Black Friday. If you don’t connect it to the internet then you’ll avoid all the issues that come with that.
LG in particular had a recent controversy about their TVs being extremely aggressive in what they collect, trying to find ways to get on the Internet, etc.
SCEPTRE has the U515CV-UMC which is a 50 inch non-smart TV.
That’s one of the ones I was googling, but I haven’t actually seen anyone selling it.
Oh stuff, I thought you just meant brands. My bad, I found a few people selling them on eBay or Facebook Marketplace. Did those not work for you?
Facebook is a straight no, but I’ll check eBay. Don’t recall even seeing any of that in my initial search results though.
I just bought a Samsung mini led tv and I can confirm you don’t need your phone or internet to “set the tv up.” Samsung initially asked for me to connect my phone for the quickest and easiest way to activate but I skipped that with a remote and it booted up just fine to the main screen. Then I plugged my Apple TV in and just use that.
At Media Markt they usually have a couple to select from, at reasonable prices.
I had a Sceptre that I liked, but it’s definitely lesser quality for the price. It gave out after 6 years. Tried to source a replacement but couldn’t get one in the size I needed. Settled on a Toshiba Fire TV from Best Buy, and it is clearly superior to both the Sceptre I had and the one I was trying to find. Needed Wi-Fi for setup but runs with it turned off. Occasionally I need to set the input, but otherwise I never touch its remote. It’s functionally a dumb monitor.










