2010 Class:
13: Brandon Graham
37: Nate Allen
86: Daniel Te’o-Nesheim
105: Trevard Lindley
121: Keenan Clayton
122: Mike Kafka
125: Clay Harbor
134: Ricky Sapp
159: Riley Cooper
200: Charles Scott
220: Jamar Chaney
243: Jeff Owens
244: Kurt Coleman
Description: Howie’s first draft was meh with the exception of Brandon Graham who is an Eagles legend but beyond Graham the rest of the 2010 class weren’t the best.
2011 Class:
23: Danny Watkins
54: Jaiquawn Jarrett
90: Curtis Marsh
116: Casey Matthews
120: Alex Henery
149: Dion Lewis
161: Julian Vandervelde
191: Jason Kelce
193: Brian Rolle
237: Greg Lloyd, Jr.
240: Stanley Havili
Description: This draft class was mostly terrible except for one man, the best center in franchise history and a legend in the 6th round. JASON KELCE Kelce is going to be in the hall of fame but the rest of this draft class with the exception of Dion Lewis are forgettable.
2012 Class:
12: Fletcher Cox
46: Mychal Kendricks
59: Vinny Curry
88: Nick Foles
123: Brandon Boykin
153: Dennis Kelly
194: Marvin McNutt
200: Brandon Washington
229: Bryce Brown
Description: This draft had a lot of good picks, Cox, Kendricks, Curry, and Foles all went down as part of the Super Bowl 52. Foles is a legend in Philly, Cox is going to the hall of fame, and both Kendricks and Curry had long careers. Dennis Kelly has had a long career as a serviceable lineman. The Eagles also hit on Brandon Boykin who had a solid 2013 season and is known for sealing the division title, and Bryce Brown who had a few good games for the Eagles.
2013 Class:
4: Lane Johnson
35: Zach Ertz
67: Bennie Logan
98: Matt Barkley
136: Earl Wolff
212: Joe Kruger
218: Jordan Poyer
239: David King
Description: The 2013 class had two more franchise legends selected Lane Johnson whose likely going to be in the hall of fame and is still an Eagle, and Zach Ertz. Both players were apart of that SB winning roster with Ertz catching the game winning TD. Bennie Logan was a solid run stopper. Jordan Poyer did not play much as an Eagle but has been a great player for the Bills. Matt Barkley was a journeyman backup.
2014 Class:
26: Marcus Smith
42: Jordan Matthews
86: Josh Huff
101: Jaylen Watkins
141: Taylor Hart
162: Ed Reynolds
224: Beau Allen
Description: This draft was a step back for Roseman, Marcus Smith, and Josh Huff were bad picks in the 1st and 3rd round, Jordan Matthews had a solid 3 year stretch but wasn’t a superstar WR. Jaylen Watkins, Taylor Hart, and Ed Reynolds had short careers. Eagles found a diamond in the rough in 7th round pick Beau Allen.
2015 Class:
Note: This class was done by Chip Kelly not Roseman so this won’t count.
2016 Class:
2: Carson Wentz
79: Isaac Seumalo
153: Wendell Smallwood
164: Halapoulivaati Vaitai
196: Blake Countess
233: Jalen Mills
240: Alex McCalister
251: Joe Walker
Description: This draft was decent with Seumalo, Wentz, Mills, Vaitai, and Smallwood all being apart of the Super Bowl winning team with Mills, Seumalo, and Vaitai being starters in the SB. As for Walker he had a solid career as a journeyman. Overall this draft class all had moments as part of the Eagles.
2017 Class:
14: Derek Barnett
43: Sidney Jones
99: Rasul Douglas
118: Mack Hollins
132: Donnel Pumphrey
166: Sheldon Gibson
184: Nate Gerry
214: Elijah Qualls
Description: This 2017 draft class was awful for the Eagles. Derek Barnett was decent but is now a depth piece who is on the trade block, and Sidney Jones was an injury ridden bust. The middle round had Rasul Dougkas and Mack Hollins leaving Philly and breaking out with other teams. Donnell Pumphrey was injury ridden, and Sheldon Gibson barley played. Nate Gerry was alright for a 6th round pick, and Elijah Qualls was a 7th.
2018 Class:
49: Dallas Goedert
125: Avonte Maddox
130: Josh Sweat
206: Matt Pryor
233: Jordan Mailata
Description: This draft class was a great class for Roseman as all of them were key members of the Eagles over the last half decade. Excluding Pryor the rest of the players were all starters on this years teams, Sweat as a PB player, and Mailata has had a hollywood story. Overall Howie made the 5 picks count as all of them have had successful careers.
2019:
22: Andre Dillard
53: Miles Sanders
57: JJ Arcega Whiteside
138: Shareef Miller
167: Clayton Thorson
Description: This draft class has been a complete disaster, with the exception of Miles Sanders who had a PB 2022 season and an overall decent stretch for the team the rest of these players have been awful. Dillard was a backup, Whiteside switched to TE, Miller was PS guy, and Thorson is out of the NFL.
2020:
21: Jalen Reagor
53: Jalen Hurts
103: Davion Taylor
127: K’von Wallace
145: Jack Driscoll
168: John Hightower
196: Shaun Bradley
200: Quez Watkins
210: Prince Tega Wanogho
233: Casey Toohill
Description: Most of this draft was awful, Jalen Reagor and Davion Taylor were awful. Reagor is a practice squad guy now, and Taylor is out of the league. K’von Wallace and Casey Toohill never developed here. John Hightower had stone for hands and was out of Philly after Y2. Despite that Shaun Bradley, Jack Driscoll, Quez Watkins, and JALEN HURTS saved this draft. Bradley being a star special teamer since coming to Philly, Watkins having his moments but is what you’d expect from a 6th round pick, and Jack Driscoll being an alright backup. Other than that you have Jalen Hurts who has exceeded expectations. Hurts turned this franchise around after an awful 4-11-1 campaign, and he has made the Eagles future filled with hope.
2021 Class:
10: Devonta Smith
37: Landon Dickerson
73: Milton Williams
123: Zech McPhearson
150: Kenneth Gainwell
189: Marlon Tuipulotu
191: Tarron Jackson
224: JaCoby Stevens
234: Patrick Johnson
Description: The 2021 draft was a massive hit for the franchise, every single pick has been great for the team. Devonta Smith, and Landon Dickerson being starters on the offense, Milton Williams being a solid player for the defensive line, Zech McPhearson a solid special teamer, and Kenneth Gainwell being a solid receiving back. Marlon Tuipulotu has been a solid rotationary depth piece, and both Patrick Johnson, and Tarron Jackson had moments, the one player whose not in the NFL is JaCoby Stevens.
2022 Class and 2023 Classes:
Note: These classes are still relatively new so it still needs another few years to see how those classes turn out.
Rankings In My Opinion:
-
2021
-
2018
-
2012
-
2013
-
2020
-
2011
-
2010
-
2016
-
2019
-
2017
-
2014
Note: 2015 is excluded due to Chip Kelly.
Largely agree, but any draft that you pick up a franchise QB from is a home run regardless of what else happens in the other rounds.