Both players are F-Tier players in their respective positions but who do you think is worse, a team featuring James Wiseman or a team featuring Scam Reddish?
Wiseman has shown the ability to be more impactful than Reddish
This statement is factual.
wiseman because he will singlehandedly tank your entire defense by just being on the floor whereas reddish is really actually decent-ish on that end (he’s actually pretty good when he decides to lock in, and mediocre when he doesn’t).
even offensively reddish won’t singlehandedly tank your team when he’s not engaged - he will just brick shots and turn the ball over but when he’s feeling lazy he just stands in the corner being invisible (which is bad, but if you play him for like 10 minutes per game he won’t destroy your team like wiseman will).