Carr 100% the better QB in a vacuum, but sticks to Carmichael’s plan too much. Winston forces the WRs to make talent plays because he throws inherently risky balls. With how talented our WRs are it makes more sense to rely on them than Carmichael’s playcalling.
TBF: The Oline yesterday was really bad for a long time. In 4 possesions in the first half they had 3 times 10+ yards on 2nd or 3rd down, due to penalties (they overcame only one of them).
We had a few plays that were great but were also called back due to penalties (we had 9 penalties for 74 yards…).
Also two drops from receivers in the first half (the bitter one from JJ).
Did Carr play great? No, but I think he is easy to blame.
He had 72% completion percentage and a 90 rating.