Okay big statement here, but I don’t think ANYONE prefers echo over Athens unholy grail.
Echos of Helia feels awkward, it feels pretty weak, and the only enchanter who consistently builds it is like… sona. I don’t understand why we have this item of Athens when it was so popular and widely enjoyed.
I think the issue is that old Athene was tied to your damage dealt which made it kinda awkward since you don’t build much damage on enchanters, but at the same time it was really interesting because it was a cool aggressive option if you wanted to be the dommy Nami that bullies the enemy assassin and then fully heals the ADC
I also think that it’d be really good for the game because currently supports and especially enchanters have no magic resistance options in their builds and it’d be nice to survive one (1) Brand ultimate without having to build Visage on Janna