If it was for me, Red Dead Redemption 2 by a mile.

Not even a contest rdr2

Definitely RDR2.

Rdr 2

First is more fun to play but second has the best open world ever created.

Red Dead 2 without a doubt in my mind

Thanks to a kind soul I now have Red Dead Redemption 2 Ultimate Edition! Happy gaming everyone!

If you must ONLY pick one, pick Red Dead

If you can get away with both, they are both excellent

Why not check to see if Sleeping Dogs is on sale?

Get red dead, horizon is MID

I pirated the game but I still want a refund

I had more fun with Horizon personally.