Every revolution was won by a small portion of the population. The idea you need the majority of people to somehow do more than voting is a false premise. The country is rules by an ultra minority, not by a majority. Revolutions win by another minority of people defeating the ruling minority of people. Communist revolutions are when that revolutionary minority are of, by, and for the majority. But the idea that the majority will strike or the majority will fight is not real and not a single theory nor historical event has ever been predicated on it
i’m calling selection bias on revolutions there, tbh. my country did recently throw out an autocrat, but we didn’t need to do a full revolution because our electoral system was still functioning enough to facilitate the change. the turks, on the other hand, had very similar movements to ours, and all of them have been thwarted by their autocracy so far, they will probably need a revolution.
but the crucial part we see in these examples is still that a movement that is able to be successful at a revolution is a movement that would have won an electoral system much earlier than it can militarily take over. if you can’t recruit the average person to tick a box on a ballot for you, you will have problem recruiting fighters to commit their lives to you, even if you technically need fewer of them.
that said, if you can somehow do that (usually through being military brass), and your revolution is genuinely unpopular and yet manages to succeed, and replaces a broken democracy with a full autocracy that doesn’t even pretend to be democratic, we call it a coup for a reason. if you are truly for the people, the only thing stopping you from convincing the people to be on your side is state propaganda, which evaporates when you take over. if you can’t transition to a democracy afterwards, you’re not the solution, you’re just the next problem in line.
Every revolution was won by a small portion of the population. The idea you need the majority of people to somehow do more than voting is a false premise. The country is rules by an ultra minority, not by a majority. Revolutions win by another minority of people defeating the ruling minority of people. Communist revolutions are when that revolutionary minority are of, by, and for the majority. But the idea that the majority will strike or the majority will fight is not real and not a single theory nor historical event has ever been predicated on it
i’m calling selection bias on revolutions there, tbh. my country did recently throw out an autocrat, but we didn’t need to do a full revolution because our electoral system was still functioning enough to facilitate the change. the turks, on the other hand, had very similar movements to ours, and all of them have been thwarted by their autocracy so far, they will probably need a revolution.
but the crucial part we see in these examples is still that a movement that is able to be successful at a revolution is a movement that would have won an electoral system much earlier than it can militarily take over. if you can’t recruit the average person to tick a box on a ballot for you, you will have problem recruiting fighters to commit their lives to you, even if you technically need fewer of them.
that said, if you can somehow do that (usually through being military brass), and your revolution is genuinely unpopular and yet manages to succeed, and replaces a broken democracy with a full autocracy that doesn’t even pretend to be democratic, we call it a coup for a reason. if you are truly for the people, the only thing stopping you from convincing the people to be on your side is state propaganda, which evaporates when you take over. if you can’t transition to a democracy afterwards, you’re not the solution, you’re just the next problem in line.
Ahistorical drivel.
that’s not a revolution, read one sentence of a wikipedia article for fucks sake.
Keep drinking that flavor aid, buddy.