Im honestly not to sure who the most overrated eagles would be. Obviously there’s plenty of past eagles I liked that weren’t ever actually that good. But I’m not sure how many were overrated. So I’ll go with a more recent player that was plenty good but I always that was overrated for our team, which is miles sanders. For as good as his numbers were guys like swift and gainwell who run harder always felt like a better fit for our offense.
First players that come to mind are those middle of the draft/late draft guys that exceeded expectations for a remote moment that everyone acted like was the new rendition of Calvin Johnson or something.
Point in case, Travis Fulgham. There were people that legitimately thought he was a starting caliber WR, a WR1, all because he had a good game before teams had tape on him and then gradually did worse and worse as defenses found more to study.