Im honestly not to sure who the most overrated eagles would be. Obviously there’s plenty of past eagles I liked that weren’t ever actually that good. But I’m not sure how many were overrated. So I’ll go with a more recent player that was plenty good but I always that was overrated for our team, which is miles sanders. For as good as his numbers were guys like swift and gainwell who run harder always felt like a better fit for our offense.
Todd Pinkston - Can’t believe he was on the team as long as he was. One year he had 113 targets and just 60 catches lol?! Never had a catch% over 57.1%
First players that come to mind are those middle of the draft/late draft guys that exceeded expectations for a remote moment that everyone acted like was the new rendition of Calvin Johnson or something.
Point in case, Travis Fulgham. There were people that legitimately thought he was a starting caliber WR, a WR1, all because he had a good game before teams had tape on him and then gradually did worse and worse as defenses found more to study.
Slay
Jason Babin. Dude fucking actually sucked ass overall he ignored all of his other responsibilities and just went for sacks. He had 18 sacks in the one season but as an actual football player he was a terrible me first player.
Vince Young. Dude was a goddamn clown and I hate that he was on this team even for a minute.
Mike Mamula.