I want to hear the theories that you gotta stretch before you reach for, but that you still genuinely believe and are willing to defend.
Vincent Adultman was actually a normal guy but bojack is an unreliable narrator and fudged the details so he didn’t seem like a jealous ex.
Yes I know theres an episode where Vincent Adultman and the kid seem like they are messing up when princess carolyn inviyes them over at the same time, but would it be out of the realm of possibility that Vincent Adultman was a man who was just too boring for bojack to actually listen to so he made up certain details. Seems very bojack…
I know Reddit hates the unreliable narrator theory for some reason, but it makes sense to me (and brings me a sigh of relief)
adding onto the theory that bj died in the pool. during the view from halfway down, the opening scene is bojack with sarah lynn giving bea a hydrangea. even tho hydrangeas are poisonous to horses. this and the bird flying into the house, i’ve seen a lot of ppl interrupte as a symbol for death. which even if bojack didn’t die, it still makes a lot of sense considering everyone in TVFHD is dead.