I know Reddit hates the unreliable narrator theory for some reason, but it makes sense to me (and brings me a sigh of relief)

Nah this makes soo much sense! And I’ve never heard anyone suggest it before. It would totally be a thing Beatrice would make up a story to cover for too, whether out of shame or genuine attempt to protect Bojack. This one is getting filed away in my brain for my next watch through!

WHOA. This is heavy and makes sense.

As far as the Hollywoob sign and the observatory, if you’re talking about their physical location relative to eachother you can see one from the other.

I just rewatched the finale and while I don’t think I’m fully convinced, I can definitely see where you’re coming from and I like this take. The wrap-up with each character did feel a bit too neat, not like how it would actually go at a wedding(even in bojack’s universe), and each conversation did give off some deathbed vibes, especially Bojack and PC.

for reallll. It’s such a bummer when people start dogpiling and stop others from sharing the bizarre connections they make in their heads and interesting theories they come up with, and all the fun stuff the subreddit should be for.

And fwiw, I don’t think the Harper thing even is a paper cup—it would still be a neat coincidence if it was, but it makes way too much sense and is just the type of detail the writers would think to include.

Do you mean the last episode was kind of like the Ruthie episode, where it all happened in one of the characters heads but not in their actual life? Or it didn’t happen at all, it was just for the audience as a ‘what if’?

Oh I’m super interested, if you want to expound. I genuinely love hearing people’s takes, no matter how far out, and I hate when the ‘it’s-not-that-deep’ police come ruin the fun.

I would count myself as one of the ones who sees themself in Bojack and definitely wants him to be okay in part because of that. But at the same time I know that’s not how life always works out. No idea if I’ll agree with your theory, but I know I’m interested in hearing it!

lmao this is amazing and I now refuse to believe it means anything else.

yeah I imagined it like this too, except ass was blowhole lol (but the scuba diving answer that people are posting in the comments ultimately makes the most sense now, which is neat)