How am I deflecting? OP shut the discussion down and added nothing.
- 0 Posts
- 10 Comments
I think we just fundamentally disagree on the causes of evil in the world. There’s no doubt in my mind the west has done terrible things but so have your country and every other country. I was hopeful that global warming or some other existential global crisis would be the catylist we need to move past this whole east vs west vs whatever mentality but I’m starting to think humans are fundamentally incapable of coexisting with each other across borders.
Do you genuinely believe eastern countries haven’t committed atrocities?
Most people are good, fewer people are willing to hurt others to further their ambitions, all countries have both types of people.
That doesn’t excuse the actions of “the west” but I think you’re lashing out, we should fight the rich and powerful people that take advantage of everyone, I just don’t think it’s a west problem, i think it’s a class problem.
Ok. That’s fair enough but OP shouldn’t be so fragile, lots of people would disagree with you about one thing or another. That shouldnt mean you’re enemies.
Tbh my understanding of anarchism is limited to what I had heard when I was a 14 year old. Wouldn’t a system like that eventually dissolve into centralised powers and basically devolve into gang and mob violence.
Democracy as in a every citizen of a country has a say in who makes decisions that effect them personally.
I don’t really get your argument, is there an example of any political system that hasn’t directly led to atrocities? I obviously condemn atrocities and I want the world to be a safer place for everyone including the people of Iraq Afghanistan, Iran and Palestine. But turning away from democracy in favour of communism seems idealistic and naive.
Which communist country would you model your countries political system on?
You must have many enemies. I’d bet we have more in common than you realise.
I sympathise with you on the moral positioning of wanting to help those in need but it’s impractical to accept every person in the world that is in need into your country. It seems more practical to allocate resources more evenly across the world and hopefully improve the places people are running from.
Disclaimer: I don’t know what I’m talking about but this feels to me like a relatively safe claim.
They’re people, they deserve the same respect as any other human being, immigration is good for some countries when the immigrants are vetted for skills your country needs, but you’re also not required to accept any person into your country. Some countries are more desired than others and population growth via immigration is a tool that has to work for the existing citizens as well. Also, whats with the communist terminology, democracy may not be perfect but it’s the best we have, I don’t trust government to run the country without the threat of an uprising to put those in power in their place and we can use all the help we can get to do that but turning to communism or authoritarianism isnt going to be better that what you have now.


Your right, I’m not well studied in any of this and my understanding is surface level. I’m sharing my thoughts in the hopes to explore and understand the topic better. Everything I’ve read has been unconvincing, I’m genuinely open to learning from everyone that disagrees with me. Alas, It’s late, thanks for the talk, sorry we couldn’t see eye to eye in the end.
Other than my grandfather, I haven’t met any other communists to discuss with so I couldn’t help jumping on this one.