• Tomorrow_Farewell@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    10
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    15 hours ago

    democracy may not be perfect but it’s the best we have

    “Democracy” as in, the Greek one, where it’s the slave-owners that are considered to be people?
    Or “democracy” in the sense that you should be held accountable for your empire’s atrocities in most of the world, including Iraq, Afghanistan, Iran, Palestine, and many other places?

    but turning to communism or authoritarianism isnt going to be better that what you have now.

    History has shown that communists provide much better living conditions to working-class people, including stuff like the 8-hour day (which your empire adopted specifically as a response to the RSFSR doing so, in order to curb communist sympathies), the criminalisation of marital SA, massively increasing life expectancy, etc.

    • AntOnARant@programming.devBanned from community
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      5
      ·
      11 hours ago

      Democracy as in a every citizen of a country has a say in who makes decisions that effect them personally.

      I don’t really get your argument, is there an example of any political system that hasn’t directly led to atrocities? I obviously condemn atrocities and I want the world to be a safer place for everyone including the people of Iraq Afghanistan, Iran and Palestine. But turning away from democracy in favour of communism seems idealistic and naive.

      Which communist country would you model your countries political system on?

      • Tomorrow_Farewell@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        6 hours ago

        Democracy as in a every citizen of a country has a say in who makes decisions that effect them personally.

        I guarantee you that you do not live in one.
        Also, if you want to claim that you do, you should be held accountable for your empire’s atrocities.

        I don’t really get your argument, is there an example of any political system that hasn’t directly led to atrocities?

        That’s a silly way to whitewash how your empire is conducting a genocide and is constantly invading somewhere. There are a lot of polities that do not do that.

        But turning away from democracy in favour of communism seems idealistic and naive.

        You don’t have to “turn away from democracy” to establish communism. Communism is democratic in the sense that a relevant society would be representing the interests of the working class.
        But let’s be honest, what you actually mean by “democracy” is representative “democracy” where the bouurgeoisie picks who runs their state and you engage in theatrics to celebrate that every few years (and you don’t even let your subjects in Africa and Asia to participate). You arbitrarily do not count, for example, the Soviet democracy as “democracy”, nor would you count any alternatives.

        Furthermore, even without achieving communism, communist revolutions led to massively improved living standards, including the 8-hour working day (which the capitalist world adopted as a response to the RSFSR, to curb communist sympathies), the criminalisation of marital SA, guaranteed housing, healthcare, education, etc.

        Which communist country would you model your countries political system on?

        I’m not particularly picky, but let’s say the USSR.