It makes zero sense to move on after one year in an offense that sucks ass, my dude. A) The morale of your team goes to shit. B) You wont get anywhere near anything worth what we gave up. C) You could very well be wrong, plenty of young QBs have sucked and then turned it around. D) We have no first round pick anyway. If BY sucks ass completely he’ll help us get a high pick in '25. When you trade up like we did and swing for the fences, if you miss, there goes at least two years. You have to accept that as the price. Jettisoning BY now makes this entire franchise an absolute joke.

Alright cool, one example. Odds are definitely against us. If you could swap CJ and BY right now you’d do it in a heartbeat. That’s kinda not at all the whole point of the post.

I think I can say some things with pretty clear certainty at this point, 10 weeks into BY’s career.

1. Stroud is the better QB and should have been the #1 pick. He would not be doing as well here, but there is literally no case ever of two rookie QBs where one balls out in year 1 and the other sucks and the careers end up reversed.

2. This does not mean BY is a bust. I agree that its impossible to truly evaluate him behind the can of beans we have blocking for him and the potatoes catching the balls and running routes. Its not his fault, but when you trade the farm for a QB you need to get someone like Stroud to have a team that is any good in the first couple of years. But I can still see watching him and watching CJ that he’s clearly not as good.

3. Reich needs to go. Now. Not at the end of the season. He is potentially permanently harming BY’s future progression with the schemes he has. I dont care who takes over for interim, but Frank should be gone on Cyber Monday.

4. Fitterer needs to go, now is fine as well. He’s had some god awful draft picks over the years. Horn over Surtain is an egregious miss especially because unlike the BY/Stroud debate, Surtain was absolutely the #1 consensus CB.

5. This isnt getting much better for at least another full year. Without the first round pick, you’re gonna need to hit on some later ones in order to get any better, and that’s always tough. Might be time to do something else on Sundays for a bit and just see.

I’m.confident in Icky, Moron, Burns, and Luvu.

DeVitos defense had six turnovers lol. You can’t possibly assume BY is a bust based on this year.

Did you watch the video or just read OP’s biased take on it? Warner says no such thing, OP is absolutely lying through his teeth.

Young’s footwork has literally always been like this. Prior to the draft, none of these analysts caught it? Really? No, it wasn’t a problem until they’re looking for a reason he’s not doing well. God if his footwork is all that’s wrong that’s fantastic. That’s fixable.

More importantly, you are lying. Warner says no such thing in his analysis and is far more critical of those around 9 than BY himself. Seems more like you are pushing an agenda here.

It’s a lot easier to blame the young guy because that’s much easier to fix.

Poles wasn’t taking another first rounder. We tried. It was either Moore, Burns, or Derrick Brown.

Absolutely not. Reich is a dinosaur and needs to go. The issue isnt just the results its the philosophy. Listen to his press conference explaining why he let Pineiro attempt a 59 yarder at soldier field. The dude is not a good coach.

Nah dude, we can completely cut ties after two years and we have all our draft picks back. If BY is a total bust, we can try again in 2025-26 for a QB. Wont take the better part of a decade. We need a great GM more than anything. Niners completely blew their #3 overall pick and they are a perennial contender.

The Panthers look like my Madden team when I intentionally burn it to the ground to actually have a challenge and try to build a team. That was absolute shite play from the offense, holy shit. Six points. Wow.

Frank Reich feels like a overprotective father. How the fuck do you not let BY take a shot at that 4th and 10, especially after converting two fourth downs on that drive? Yeah he got fooled bad the previous play, but damn are you a reactionary motherfucker if that was the reason for not going for it.

There is no way on the planet Eddie P is making a 59 yarder in Soldier Field. He’s a great accurate kicker, he’s not going to boom it. Justin Tucker would have a tough time with a 59 yarder in Soldier Field.

What an absolutely stupid coaching decision to end the game. Reich and the whole staff- minus the D coord- need to go.

Wow this is absolutely fantastic!

Burrow is so fucking awesome to listen to haha. I’ve watched this twice now.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=adtruA-WU10

“Where do you want him to go with the ball?”

Its easy to say “Bryce is the problem” without actually looking at the gametape. Its always easy to point out the issue and not how to fix it.