It boils down to this, and I don’t understand why no one understands:

Our offense is good enough and proven enough to do well 75% of the time. On the 25% of the time it doesn’t, the defense never does its job to help even the whole team out. Talk about the offense never helping the D.

They continue to fail. In most, if not all, our wins, the offense either had to go up two scores or score every drive to match. Maybe in the Seattle game at the end with Analzone’s sack and in last week’s Bears game getting that last drive 3 and out stop then the Hutch safety. Every other point we played mid to bad offenses.

The only time our D does good is when a skill player finally shows up. It’s nothing AG is doing that’s making our defense thrive. Our skill players make him look way better than he is.

I’m still not at full fire AG mode, but these things are clear, and he needs to figure something out.

Everyone has some good takes in this thread. Obviously, based on the era, the right answer is Barry or Calvin. Current would be like St. Brown, Hutch, Jamo, Gibbs, or Goff.

But im here to throw a curveball, and I think my era of fans (started watching right after 0-16) would agree that after Megatron, the most exciting players to watch was the QB position. Yes I said that right. Stafford and Hill. Touted as the best 1&2 QB in the league for a few years. I remember people talking about how Hill was the best backup QB in the league. So the few times he played, I was all eyes. He was mid of course, but that was something that always sticks with me. Ol’ Shaun Hill.

Honorable mentions: Javid Best, Bush and Bell tandem, Durham, Tate, Big Play Slay, Glover Quinn. Stafford Fake spike.

Trust me I’m watching the same game yall are. BUT, how isn’t Gardner a starter in the league? He’s average at BEST but i could name like 4 teams he’d instantly improve.

Lol he tried to carry Mac to the 1st down

Daaaaamn