• 2 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 22nd, 2023

help-circle
  • Shoo…

    On one hand, that one looks pretty clean, all things considered (no pictures of underbody to show possible leaks). At the same time… man that’s a lot of money to spend on a car that frankly is a PITA to drive in town. I have an '81 Targa, and I’d sell mine for … maybe not half that, but definitely less than that. I also have an '86 951 that’s been tastefully upgraded with more modern performance mods (e.g. rebuilt turbo, new pistons, mass airflow sensor, sleeved cylinders, etc) that I might consider selling for half of that price - and trust me an '86 951 is way easier to live with and more fun to drive than a base '86 911.

    I mean… $87k is easy 991 money these days. Yes, a 991 isn’t a classic, but there’s a lot you have to put up with on these older cars. I would not call $87k for an '86 3.2 a “good deal”. For reference, right now Hagerty considers a #2 to be an $85k car, and a #3 to be a $50k car. A 90,000 mile #2 car is… not a thing. “Could win a regional car show, drives like new.” 4 Owners, no mention of previous work or service history. This is very likely #2 money for a #3 car, and I wouldn’t pay it.

    If it had a full service history (with receipts), a clean PPI and the paint was immaculate, I *might* consider going $80k for it. But absent any of those things I think $60-65 is probably more realistic.





  • jdub-951BtoPorsche@gearhead.townWhich would you buy?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    One thing to keep in mind is that G-bodies (especially SC’s, which you’re looking at) are generally pretty reliable once you get them sorted. Yes, they are 40 year old cars and are going to have issues, but they’re substantially better than a lot of other cars from the same vintage. There was a video a few years back from the Manhattan Classic Car Club talking about 911’s, and their comment about why the air-cooled’s were great was that, “They have a ton of character, but they don’t have *so much* character that you are worried that they’re not going to start when you want to drive them.”

    Other than that, people have mostly hit the high notes. They’re different cars. The old 911 is visceral and very, very analogue. The 997 is going to have a lot more creature comforts.

    Personally, I would likely get the newer car, but I also *have* the older car, and the grass is always greener? But either would be a fun car.