They are too harsh on 50-50s and any challenge where studs hit. Sure, those tackles are dangerous but many are accidental.

They’re not harsh enough on second yellow card offenses, they let players go crazy and walk free. This is largely a consequence of VAR not being able to give yellow cards. Rule should be changed so that it can.

Also don’t seem to be hard enough on violent conduct. Romero should’ve been off for kicking out, Guimaraes should’ve been off for striking a players face. These are a bit more perplexing, chalk it up to the officials being stupid and not reading the laws of the game.

So IMO, they need to give more yellow cards rather than red for legitimate challenges, more consistent second yellow cards, and more red cards for violent conduct.

malacia is a good signing tho. He was cheap and seems decent. He’s just been injured for a while.

that is a good point. They’ve definitely helped us once or twice, but I would say he has been average to below at both creating and finishing.

The end product from his runs has definitely been due to his aerial dominance