First thing that comes to mind is Watson from a Sherlock Holmes videogame. Was meant to just stay close to Sherlock, but ended up working like a weeping angel. Any other good examples of things that weren’t meant to give the spooks but ended up doing so anyway?
A lot of stuff from Bully. A ton of eerie, liminal spaced in that game with a slightly “off” vibe.
Dead Rising mannequins
The dead eyed npcs and lifeless conversations and dialogue of the elder scrolls franchise. Too many are uncanny, especially Oblivion.
Lots of Zelda stuff borders between weird/creepy/funny and its hard to tell when it’s intentional or not, especially in the darker titles like Majora’s Mask and Twilight Princess. Like Twilight Princess was intentionally creepy in tone, but were the little kids supposed to be? And Majora’s Mask is all over the place…
When I was young, I got really into Lego Star Wars 3. There was a level called “Innocents of Ryloth.” For some reason, the calm music when there was no combat happening really freaked me out so I didn’t touch the game for a while. The next time I played it, I sped straight to the next combat section as quickly as possible to avoid the music
Collecting korok poop count?
The Motel in gta san Andreas.
Diving in Far Cry 4.
Subnautica, the whole thing.
Diving in GTA V.
I have a problem with water in games.