Dunno, but Cunningham is still my favorite stud athlete QB.
Anyone who only punts several times in his life and holds third longest punt ever is special. actually it was a quick kick
Still McNabb for now but I think Hurts will surpass him within the next few years. Even when accounting for a more passer friendly era, Hurts is just a far more accurate QB.
Also, Randall should be on here as well.
-
McNabb
-
Hurts
-
Wentz
-
Vick
Hurts hasn’t played long enough to pass McNabb, but can do so if he maintains his current level for another three, maybe four seasons after this one.
-
Half the people in this thread thinking it’s ranking the top 4 QBs in Eagles history, when the title just says to rank the 4 pictured quarterbacks.
5-1-7-11
I think the top two will switch soon though.
Based on their time as Eagles
5 - Superbowl appearance and many NFCC appearance
Hurts - Superbowl appearance
Wentz - Instrumental in Superbowl season
Vick - Some fun regular season gamesCareer: McNabb, Vick, Hurts, Wentz Single season: Wentz, Hurts, McNabb, Vick
I know he wasn’t the best but mike Vick made me fall in love with the eagles and football
Best to least: Wentz, Hurts, McNabb, Vick
If we’re talking all time I’m sorry but I’m gonna put Vick over McNabb, his time in Atlanta was unlike anything I’ve ever seen
- Mcnabb
- Vick
- Peak Wentz
- Hurts
- Other Wentz
If we go by peak performance
- 2010 Vick
- 2017 Wentz
- 2022 Hurts
- 2004 McNabb
I’m adding Foles to the list because adding Vick and Wentz without Foles is downright criminal. And added Jaws and Cunningham because they’re above most of these guys.
- McNabb - Accomplishments + Longevity
- Jaworski - One of our most accomplished QBs and took us to our first SB.
- Cunningham - My favorite Eagles’ QB and the reason I’m a football fan. Vick before Vick existed, but he had a long career here. For one year I was a Vikings fan (though I’m only counting his time with the Eagles here).
- Foles - Two great seasons and a SB MVP
- Hurts - He’ll surpass Foles this year if we win the SB with him. Even without the SB win, he surpasses Foles pretty soon.
- Wentz - Had what should have been an MVP season and showed potential. But injuries and his ego took a toll.
- Vick - Exciting but short lived. On par with Wentz except that Carson had that near-MVP year.
Foles’ SB win + MVP elevates him, but he’s the least talented guy on this list. Hurts has the potential to top this list when it’s all said and done. At minimum a SB win this year moves him ahead of Foles.
I wouldn’t. It’s an unnecessary, divisive exercise.
1,5,7,11