I sympathise with you on the moral positioning of wanting to help those in need but it’s impractical to accept every person in the world that is in need into your country. It seems more practical to allocate resources more evenly across the world and hopefully improve the places people are running from.
Disclaimer: I don’t know what I’m talking about but this feels to me like a relatively safe claim.
I sympathise with you on the moral positioning of wanting to help those in need but it’s impractical to accept every person in the world that is in need into your country.
impractical because western countries keep making refugees by bombing and destroying their homes
Then to make them more scared and subservient, make it always known that they are not welcome, that they are foreign, that they are leeches of society and that they should be grateful to be even able to kiss the ground of western society.
Do you genuinely believe eastern countries haven’t committed atrocities?
Most people are good, fewer people are willing to hurt others to further their ambitions, all countries have both types of people.
That doesn’t excuse the actions of “the west” but I think you’re lashing out, we should fight the rich and powerful people that take advantage of everyone, I just don’t think it’s a west problem, i think it’s a class problem.
Do you genuinely believe eastern countries haven’t committed atrocities?
That are backed by western interests.
Most people are good, fewer people are willing to hurt others to further their ambitions, all countries have both types of people.
Yes that’s why you shouldn’t be defending systems that are upheld by evil people.
That doesn’t excuse the actions of “the west” but I think you’re lashing out, we should fight the rich and powerful people that take advantage of everyone, I just don’t think it’s a west problem, i think it’s a class problem.
The west has 700+ military bases around the world. Who are always involved in wars against the global south, who are always exploiting said countries. And the problem, is that defending the west is defending the violence. There is no equal exchange, the western empire have been doing this forever. I recommend reading Imperialism, the Highest State of Capitalism
You are right about it being a class problem, of course.
I think we just fundamentally disagree on the causes of evil in the world. There’s no doubt in my mind the west has done terrible things but so have your country and every other country. I was hopeful that global warming or some other existential global crisis would be the catylist we need to move past this whole east vs west vs whatever mentality but I’m starting to think humans are fundamentally incapable of coexisting with each other across borders.
I’m starting to think humans are fundamentally incapable of coexisting with each other across borders.
Ecofascism like this and doomscrolling seem to have the same source – ignorance of the reasons why the state of the world is the condition that it’s in – and I don’t blame then since I also grew up in the same environment and believed the same things until I started learning from non-western sources.
I was hopeful that global warming or some other existential global crisis would be the catylist we need to move past this whole east vs west vs whatever mentality
It is the western society that exports their polluting industries into the global south while simultaneously condemning them for the pollution. The oil companies making the world warmer are all western and they control the policies that the west brutally enforces on the rest of the world.
but I’m starting to think humans are fundamentally incapable of coexisting with each other across borders.
This is thinking like a fascist. Do some introspection because this is fucking disgusting
You have a surface level understanding of the issue. No one is saying that eastern countries have not committed atrocities. It is that the western countries have been the imperialist powers for 500 years and have dominated the globe. They are not equivalent in their scale.
You think you are making a good point but to studied people your point is that of a child’s understanding.
Your right, I’m not well studied in any of this and my understanding is surface level. I’m sharing my thoughts in the hopes to explore and understand the topic better. Everything I’ve read has been unconvincing, I’m genuinely open to learning from everyone that disagrees with me. Alas, It’s late, thanks for the talk, sorry we couldn’t see eye to eye in the end.
Other than my grandfather, I haven’t met any other communists to discuss with so I couldn’t help jumping on this one.
I think your intention is clear and uhatefull, so no need to justify your statement.
This issue is not white or black, of course it’s never ok if a person is struggling to find a living wage in his country or twon to top that with forcing him to accept other layers of immigration,i mean this will only makes his struggles more hard, so that makes no sense and will create frustrations that are easily channeled towards hate speech and illogical fear of others.
However, the root cause of this paradox is not immigrations, its late stage capitalism and what comes with it of that cultural acceptance of pesudo western superiority or supremacy.
The reality of a capitalist system first pillar is human labor exploitation and the minute your efforts as a worker can be replaced to maximize the profit (surplus value) the system will then butcher you.
However in a capitalism system the root cause should not be known to the masses so propaganda must be produced and channeled by that same system to distract beneficiaries of westerns imperialism towards the easier target (poor immigrants that come from lands that where destroyed by western imperialism)
I sympathise with you on the moral positioning of wanting to help those in need but it’s impractical to accept every person in the world that is in need into your country. It seems more practical to allocate resources more evenly across the world and hopefully improve the places people are running from.
Disclaimer: I don’t know what I’m talking about but this feels to me like a relatively safe claim.
impractical because western countries keep making refugees by bombing and destroying their homes
Then to make them more scared and subservient, make it always known that they are not welcome, that they are foreign, that they are leeches of society and that they should be grateful to be even able to kiss the ground of western society.
Do you genuinely believe eastern countries haven’t committed atrocities?
Most people are good, fewer people are willing to hurt others to further their ambitions, all countries have both types of people.
That doesn’t excuse the actions of “the west” but I think you’re lashing out, we should fight the rich and powerful people that take advantage of everyone, I just don’t think it’s a west problem, i think it’s a class problem.
That are backed by western interests.
Yes that’s why you shouldn’t be defending systems that are upheld by evil people.
The west has 700+ military bases around the world. Who are always involved in wars against the global south, who are always exploiting said countries. And the problem, is that defending the west is defending the violence. There is no equal exchange, the western empire have been doing this forever. I recommend reading Imperialism, the Highest State of Capitalism
You are right about it being a class problem, of course.
I think we just fundamentally disagree on the causes of evil in the world. There’s no doubt in my mind the west has done terrible things but so have your country and every other country. I was hopeful that global warming or some other existential global crisis would be the catylist we need to move past this whole east vs west vs whatever mentality but I’m starting to think humans are fundamentally incapable of coexisting with each other across borders.
Ecofascism like this and doomscrolling seem to have the same source – ignorance of the reasons why the state of the world is the condition that it’s in – and I don’t blame then since I also grew up in the same environment and believed the same things until I started learning from non-western sources.
It is the western society that exports their polluting industries into the global south while simultaneously condemning them for the pollution. The oil companies making the world warmer are all western and they control the policies that the west brutally enforces on the rest of the world.
This is thinking like a fascist. Do some introspection because this is fucking disgusting
You have a surface level understanding of the issue. No one is saying that eastern countries have not committed atrocities. It is that the western countries have been the imperialist powers for 500 years and have dominated the globe. They are not equivalent in their scale.
You think you are making a good point but to studied people your point is that of a child’s understanding.
Your right, I’m not well studied in any of this and my understanding is surface level. I’m sharing my thoughts in the hopes to explore and understand the topic better. Everything I’ve read has been unconvincing, I’m genuinely open to learning from everyone that disagrees with me. Alas, It’s late, thanks for the talk, sorry we couldn’t see eye to eye in the end.
Other than my grandfather, I haven’t met any other communists to discuss with so I couldn’t help jumping on this one.
I think your intention is clear and uhatefull, so no need to justify your statement.
This issue is not white or black, of course it’s never ok if a person is struggling to find a living wage in his country or twon to top that with forcing him to accept other layers of immigration,i mean this will only makes his struggles more hard, so that makes no sense and will create frustrations that are easily channeled towards hate speech and illogical fear of others.
However, the root cause of this paradox is not immigrations, its late stage capitalism and what comes with it of that cultural acceptance of pesudo western superiority or supremacy.
The reality of a capitalist system first pillar is human labor exploitation and the minute your efforts as a worker can be replaced to maximize the profit (surplus value) the system will then butcher you.
However in a capitalism system the root cause should not be known to the masses so propaganda must be produced and channeled by that same system to distract beneficiaries of westerns imperialism towards the easier target (poor immigrants that come from lands that where destroyed by western imperialism)
These 2 contradict
Again with 2 contradictory statements.