• 2 Posts
  • 24 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 16th, 2023

help-circle









  • There’s a lot to unpack here. There are so many things to argue with. And value is what you are willing to pay for it, etc.

    But honestly that’s being silly. This list doesn’t matter in the least and it’s a fun thought experiment.

    In the spirit of your post, I’m going to say that IWC should move down one and Chopard up at least one — personally I would put it on the FU prices row, though the fact is you should never pay list for a Chopard. Breitling I would absolutely put on the FU row, this sub is strange in its contempt for the brand, and you also should never pay list for one.

    I won’t risk my neck by saying where I think Tudor should go.

    Ulysse Nardin is… I think they do fascinating yet hideous mechanical things and are basically what Hublot wants to be when it grows up. And therefore should be on the bottom row unless you’re realllllly into mermaid pornography you wear on your body.

    AP is almost impossible to even truly place on this list, i would almost put them in the bottom row were it not for their tradition and still being family-owned (if not for the Royal Oak they probably wouldn’t be). I also think AP doesn’t give two figs what we think of them down here in the cheap seats lol.

    I respect JLC but am struggling to consider them innovative, not in 2023.

    The “Super but cost too much” row should be named “I think Monsieur has mistakenly entered the wrong establishment. Shall I call security or a taxi?”